The Critique on The Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison --Good, Bad, Ichy.
Okay, I read it. It took me a while. I read it in my car, mostly, between stops and traffic. I have read a couple or three books that way. A comedian/senator's memoir... What else?
Now enter Ralph Ellison. Yes, this book was a slog. I told people I did not like it, I did not enjoy it. For most of it. I asked a co-worker if it would get better the last fifty pages or so. He thought that as I not liked it so far, the last part would not get much better. And he was mostly right. Same sloggy, blechy, ichy stuff with the character and the plot and the events.
Then I read the Epilogue. Okay, Ralph. Something in the Epilogue got me wondering, thinking, somewhat enjoying it. It was better than the forst 570 or so pages of the book.
Ralph, to you: You have fine words, fine turns of phrases. Some good writing and letters are obviously in there. The characters? I could see them, I could feel them. But sometimes I forgot who was who; perhaps their fictional natures left them too cartoonish in my mind. Was that your point?
Caricatures and cartoons more than real flesh and blood? I saw the realness in them. I could feel the humanity.
Speaking of humanity, this is a classic or giant work in the realm of the African-American world, and therefore among the biggest among the whole United States, and therefore the world. Humanity as we know it. Important. That is why I read it, bottom line. I had heard about this novel for decades now.
How is this man invisible? How does it apply to Black people? To me? To the rest of us?
My son had to read it for his high school class the last year or two. As I read it this year, sometime starting in 2026 (or 2025?), I seriously wondered why this book would be required for kids in their teens.
Problems. Nudity and salaciousness, adultery and prurience, all kinds of ribald words and thoughts, the likes of which that I studied or tried to master for my Master level GRE test.
Yes, Ralph, you were too dirty. But in my way of seeing things, worse than sexually weird and flippant, you were sexist, or misogynist, or just plain: unfair? Overly simplistic? Hmmmm...
You talk about your nothingness, or invisibility, or your impotence, (metaphorical). Is it the legacy of slavery, human bondage, the Black experience, the travails and trials of racism and poverty and subjugation, discrimination and poverty?
Sure. I believe it. You are invisible. You are a nothing, despite your hardest attempts at trying to overcome.
Being young and Black and idealistic in a corrupt, jaded world, from the South to the great Gotham of New York. Right after the the Biggest World War, in the late 1940s. A book whose, or which, its time had come. It impressed many and stuck with us for decades, up to my boy in his suburban school this past year or two. I wanted to read his paper about it, what was so compelling or worthwhile.
I hope that he still has it.
I want to write his English teacher, a person who teaches in a decent environment, at a school referring to the great mastery of God over all. His Dominion, if you will. Like the state we live in.
This is God's plight and mastery, Mr. Ellison.
Yes, I thought the book was hard and uneasy, and not that virtuous or noble. I suppose it had some ideas, some bordering profound or significant, but I had a hard time.
Is it because I am not Black? Or... I look for too much less ichiness? Or more "there" there.
Yes, as my professor at UCLA Barbara Geddes (not the baby artist, or yes?), when speaking of little substance: "there is not much or little "there" there.
But apparently Ralph filled his tome full of substantial things.
Did he. Did he?
I need it spelled out and diagrammed more.
Otherwise it is painful and lacking. The epilogue made some sense. Hard though that was.
Deeper thoughts and ideas, per the whole, par the course.
All right, I will lead it till there.
Not the end, only the beginning, I think.